articles

Where to Get Thanksgiving Dinner in and around North Brookhaven

November 18, 2020

The Bench (Stony Brook)

  • 4/8/12 person options
  • Must be ordered by 11/23

Marino & Sons Meats (Centereach)

  • Several packages to choose from including just a dessert package
  • Visit our Online Market.  marinomeats.com Order Online or By Phone. 631-588-4152

Setauket Gourmet Delicatessen & Caterers (East Setauket)

  • Packages, sides, appetizers, desserts, and more available 
  • Order by 11/20

Fifth Season Restaurant (Port Jefferson)

  • View the full Thanksgiving Package Menu on our website thefifth-season.com
  • Call at 631-477-8500 ext 2 to place orders and reserve your pickup time slot!

Uncle Giuseppe's Marketplace (Port Jefferson)

  • Catering, turkey in a bag, and online ordering is available

Struggletown BBQ (Mount Sinai)

  • Different sized packages plus side options, and extra meal options
  • Delivery to your home free of charge

Town & Country Market (Miller Place)

  • Individual catering options to make up your own customized order

Tuscany Gourmet Market (Miller Place)

  • Offering a wide range of holiday food for Thanksgiving and Christmas

Orto (Miller Place)

  • Offering in-restaurant, pick up and catering options
  • Order by 11/22

What's For Dinnah (Sound Beach)

  • Sides, pies and desserts

Broadway Market (Rocky Point)

  • Order by 11/22 

Fresh n Fit Meals (Rocky Point)

  • Pre-Thanksgiving grab and go meal prep Thanksgiving-themed meals

The Country Rotisserie (Shoreham) 631-369-4200

  • Large Holiday Meal: serves 10-14 guests
  • Fresh Turkey Breast Meal: serves 4-6 guests
  • Must be ordered at least 72 hours in advance

Chubs Meats (Medford)

  • 3 packages to choose from, sides and appetizers

Looking for some sweets or desserts?

Tilda's Bake Shop (Rocky Point)

  • We have all your favorite breads, pastries, pies and more. Something for everyone whether it’s gluten free, sugar free or vegan. Call your order in at (631)-821-CAKE (2253) or come visit us all week long, except for Monday.

Justin Bakewicz Farms (Wading River)

  • Now accepting orders for pies and donuts for thanksgiving! You can email us your order and information at bakewiczfarms@optonline.net or you can call our office at 6318491120!  
  • We are making FULL-SIZED apple pies, “fruits of the forest” pies, dutch apple pies, pumpkin pies and blueberry pies. We will also be making MINI apple, blueberry, very berry, and pumpkin pies also! And last but not least, apple cider donuts!  Get your orders in today

Andrew's Family Farm (Wading River)

  • Pie Orders for pickup available

If you need a little help this Thanksgiving, reach out to these local businesses:

Golden Jalapenos Cafe (Middle Island)

  • Come join us for  free Thanksgiving   meals we will be delivering as well  for veterans and senior citizens in 833 Middle Country Road Golden jalapeños in Middle Island 631 448 8907  631 504 6667

Branches Long Island (Middle Island)